We Do Need Governance, But Can Do Without Sovereignty

I just finished reading my friend Bernie Wills' book Believing Weird Things. I’m writing a review of it at Social Epistemology, but today’s monologue will work through some of my initial reactions to what he had to say. As well, I’m going to see what can come out of playing Bernie’s ideas off some arguments from Antonio Negri’s latest book Assembly, available in intelligent bookshops and online stores near you.

So the last two essays of the fourteen in Believing Weird Things were published on the open-access side of Social Epistemology early this year. They confront different aspects of the resurgence of nationalist politics in Europe and the Americas. 

I’ll expand a little more on this in my official review, of course. But the last essay, “Conservatism: The End of An Idea” made me think of a curious idea. It wasn’t something he said, but something he never said.

The essay identified and explored the nihilism driving all the most radically destructive forms of extremism. 

Since the show is called Radical Democrats Radio, I thought I’d at least consider the implications for the brand. 

If I can distill the argument to a single sentence – Bernie saw the nihilism of nationalist right and anarchist left ultimately leading to the same ends. The radical nationalist replaces rule of law with fascist kleptocracy. The radical anarchist replaces rule of law with social chaos.

Here’s my problem with this idea. I think it departs from the material situation we’re in, veering a little too conceptual. 

In the actual political situation of Europe and the Americas in 2018, our popular political conflicts are realigning into a new order. 

The general right wing blends two ideologies: 1) economic libertarianism that enables cronyism and kleptocracy, 2) xenophobic nationalism. The particular flavour of xenophobia in a country, is usually cobbled together from what’s available. 

For example, xenophobes in the United States are deepest dedicated to being anti-Hispanic and anti-Black, and Islamophobia is a bold new vector of aggressive racist paranoia. They’ve resurrected their fear-mongering anti-communist messaging to describe anything in favour of a welfare state, environmentalism, or social liberalism in general. The most extreme xenophobes are more marginalized Nazis.

I say more marginalized because you can’t say k-i-k-e on FOX. At least not yet. So I’m speaking relatively.

Bernie’s right about that designation. So what about the left? 

Well, I’ve hung out in some pleasant anarchist communes. But they aren’t exactly networked into the new progressive mainstream. Because the conservative mainstream includes open dedicated racists like US Representative Steve King, FOX News’ Tucker Carlson, Presidential Advisor Stephen Miller, and President Donald Trump.

Today’s new alignment in the progressive left is toward a new social democracy that includes ecological priorities in its economics, and a cosmopolitan ethnic, religious, sex, and gender freedom in its cultural liberalism. 

An essay that seeks to diagnose our times leans too heavily on a concept instead of the real. That’s my main problem with that last essay in the collection. 

Yet. I have to say yet. There is a very subtle kind of opposition to the state that the 21st century social democrats of the West share with the most nitrous-addled anarchist shack-dweller. It’s the opposition to sovereignty.

Sovereignty is a conceptual framework of what governments are for. But a government can be organized according to a lot of different conceptual frameworks. Sovereignty is an ideology that unites two principles – 1) Borders become sanctified; 2) A state’s borders create a united social entity, the nation.

This is what Negri diagnoses. Sovereignty ideology defines the purpose of the state as maintaining the population in order. So the primary institutions of the state are the police and military.

The new social democratic vision defines the purpose of the state real economic and personal freedom. Everyone has the capacity and opportunities to make a decent living and avoid indebtedness. Everyone has the right to live however and wherever they want. 

What are the institutions of a state with those priorities? It’s not keeping order. It’s about preserving the lives and dignity of the population. Those institutions would be public health infrastructure, social security, schools and universities. 

This wouldn’t be a sovereign state that prioritizes social order. It would be a people’s state that prioritizes social dignity. 


  1. Well these are indeed things I am working on for the sequel including some things I think thought through by the anarchist wing of the left and that is basically the question of authority...the fact that as Rousseau says force cannot establish right...anarchist are generally pleasant folk but like many on left and right are prey to a tradition that fetishizes violence in uncritical way...thus you get folk you know wouldn't hurt a flea talking about beating people in the streets...so when I talk about social chaos that is what I mean...unaccountable claims to the summary uses of force

  2. that's why think my essay on violence is the one people should use as a key to the last two...if I may make a suggestion....

  3. In this I am close to what Richard Matthews is trying to say

  4. Công ty dịch thuật Bình Dương 123 Lê Trọng Tấn Dĩ An, Bình Dương là công ty cung cấp dịch vụ dịch thuật hàng đầu trong số những công ty dịch thuật chuyên cung cấp dịch vụ dịch thuật chuyên nghiệp tại Bình Dương. Trải qua hơn 10 năm tồn tại và phát triển tới nay chúng tôi tự hào vì cung cấp dịch vụ dịch thuật cho hơn 100.000 khách hàng, với hơn 500.000 bản dịch thuộc mọi ngôn ngữ, chuyên ngành.Hiện tại công ty chúng tôi đang cung cấp các dịch vụ dịch thuật, dịch vụ phiên dịch, dịch công chứng uy tín, đảm bảo cho mọi cá nhân và tổ chức trong và ngoài nước. Ngoài những nỗ lực về đảm bảo tính chính xác và hoàn hảo của bản dịch, Công ty chúng tôi luôn chú trọng đến việc quản lý dự án chuyên dụng và tối ưu dịch vụ khách hàng.
    Các giám đốc dự án của chúng tôi có thể tiếp cận được vào tất cả các nguồn lực làm việc đảm bảo dự án của khách hàng được quản lý theo đúng tiêu chuẩn, tiến độ và thời gian đã đề ra.
    chúng tôi mặc định rằng mỗi khách hàng của mình đều là những đối tác quan trọng và quý khách hàng luôn được quan tâm ở mức tối đa. Hãy liên hệ ngay với chúng tôi khi bạn có dự án cần dịch thuật
    Chi tiết liên hệ:
    Liên hệ Công ty dịch thuật Bình Dương
    Địa chỉ: 123 Lê Trọng Tấn, Dĩ An, Bình Dương
    Hotline: Mr. Khương CEO: 0947.688.883 – Mr. Hùng 0963 918438

  5. Thanks for sharing this information.
    Yes Done is the best online site for on demand home services, professional service providers in Jaipur, Rajasthan. We are providing top services like carpenter, cleaning, TV, best pest control services in Jaipur, ro repair service in Jaipur, ac repair service in Jaipur online by Yes Done is there for services at your doorstep in Jaipur, Rajasthan. For more service visit our website. For more services visit our website.

  6. It's a great blog, shares a piece of good information.

    GIEC Global is the leading education and migration consultants in Australia. We are top Education consultants in Melbourne, Sydney, Perth, Brisbane, Adelaide and Australia. We are best education consultants for Canada in Australia. We also helps people in studying in USA and have been awarded as education consultants for USA in Melbourne and education consultant for UK in Australia.

  7. The awesome blog shares good information with everyone. I will bookmark it in the future.

    France Education Consultants in Australia is GIEC Global. We are top Education consultants for Norway in Melbourne, Sydney, Perth, Brisbane, Adelaide and Australia. We are best education consultants for Netherlands in Australia. We also helps people in studying in Ireland and have been awarded as education consultants for Ireland in Melbourne and education consultant for Finland in Australia.

  8. Nice Blog, worth reading it. I have also bookmarked it for the future.

    If you are looking to Work in Australia , Work in Canada, Work in USA, Work in UK, or Work in Ireland then GIEC Global will be the best consultant for you in Australia.